Rhythm: Three note chords - Why?
Monday, February 8, 2010 at 7:50AM Because of a comment on another post, I realized that I hadn't cover why the classic swing rhythm guitar voicings are three notes.
Consider the rhythm guitarist in a swing band: Allan Reuss in Goodman's Band, Freddie Green in Basie's, etc. It's you and your acoustic archtop versus 10 to 13 horns. You have to cut through and still provide the pulse. The answer is a three note chord.
While it might seem counter-intuitive that playing less notes will be heard better than more notes, but you have to think about being a knife. In a big band, the bass player, bass drum, the trombones and the left hand of the piano are below you, and the trumpets, saxes, cymbals, and the right hand of the piano are above you. In between all of these voices is a small notch - that's where the rhythm guitar goes. By filling that notch, and not trying to play any other notes, you're acting as knife, slicing through the mix.
If you play higher and lower notes, they'll just get lost in the mix of the other instruments. But the notes (especially on the D and G strings) can cut through the band. Think of that space as a hole in enemy lines - you need to get a small special forces squad through unnoticed, not try to cram a battalion through. Playing more notes in a big band just muddies things up. It blunts the rhythmic impact (which is really the primary thing), and it results in a lot of wasted effort.
Acoustic archtop guitars happen to have their natural peak in the mid-range on the D and G strings, between the 5th and 10th frets - basically prime rhythm guitar chord territory. By focusing on that region, you get the best return on your efforts.
When people talk about Freddie Green playing only or two note chords, he would basically be fingering the classic three note voices, but not fully pushing down the bass string, and/or or the G string. He would be focusing on the D and G strings for the maximum punch and cut.
I generally stick to the classic three note voicings for 90% of playing. Sometimes, in a bigger band, I'll drop the bass string. And sometimes, in a trio setting, I might add a fourth note, but I also might not. By focusing on only playing those three notes, it is also easier to check the rhythmic snap needed for the style.
Reader Comments (5)
I'm obsessed with 3-note rhythm guitar/Freddie Green comping...whatever you'd like to call it. I think the method should be more wide-spread especially for those who want to dabble in a swing styling. There's magic in 3 note jazz chords moving up and down the guitar neck. Deceivingly simple but sophisticated imho.
This site and freddiegreen.org have been quite useful for my studies. Thanks Mr. Stout!
contented mind is the greatest blessing a man can enjoy in this world.-Audemars Piguet Jules Audemars watches Swiss
Thank you for sharing your stories, your opinions, your thoughts and your life. I like your article.Fashion is a forever topic. Everyone loves beautiful things and wants to be beautiful or handsome. Top quality products will help you. Maybe you can have a look at my website. jkxezo jkxezo - yves saint laurent sandales.
I like the writing structure of your blog and it does a pretty decent job of presenting the material. dtfjsf dtfjsf - red bottom sole.
Mulberry Handbags has become the first line of the brand Mulberry Bags, and their success is not measured in Mulberry UK action, Mulberry Sale has had a long investigation and analysis, continuous Mulberry Handbags Sale improvement and enrichment has Mulberry Bags UK a huge trend Mulberry Alexa in the world as the most representative and Mulberry Bayswater critical success factors that Mulberry Clutch Bags pattern bags may not interchangeable, other Mulberry Cross Body Bags, and there's no doubt about Mulberry Hobo. Monogram bag has a recognizable Mulberry Shoulder Bags pattern combinations initials Mulberry Messenger Bags and floral patterns, everyone knows Light-Grey Mulberry Bayswater Anthracite Ostrich Holdalls Bag change that difference, regardless of the Mulberry Daria Clutch Purse Black and no matter what happens, Mulberry Slim Brynmore in Navy Smooth Touch is important to be ignored, and although there are a variety of styles, patterns Mulberry Handbags Charm Roomy Dark Orange is still the center of the design Mulberry Daria Soft Leather Cross Body Bag Purple that will be mainly divided into several obvious reasons.
<p>Own more than 100 years history, Mulberry Bag is most people’s favorite for it’s real leather material and exterior originality. Fashion mulberry design with more pockets, buckles and more beautiful with practical with rivets, make the mulberry popularity worldwide. Specialized in the leather, forged by masterly craft, Mulberry Factory Shop sale Mulberry Handbags, Mulberry Alexa,Bags, Mulberry Bayswater Bags, Mulberry Clutch Bags, Mulberry Purse, Mulberry Hobo Bags,etc. Top quality Mulberry sale in the Mulberry UK Shop, combined with the practical, creating original and leather tactility, Mulberry Handbags UK try to be unique creative design. Full collection of Mulberry Bags with different leather materials and sizes in the Mulberry Bag online shop, mulberry calf leather bags, mulberry ostrich leather bags, mulberry buffalo leather bags,etc. Mulberry oversized, Mulberry big size, Mulberry small size,etc. Welcome to our store, mulberry outlet all kinds of high quality mulberry bags to you, free shipping! </p>
<p>To find a suitable handbags is very important to people’s image, and where to find the most suitable bag to enhance self image? Mulberry Factory shop have full collection of Mulberry Bags let you choose. Luxury British top brand Mulberry own more than 100 years history and has long been recognized for its highly crafted fine leather goods. Use different materials design various Mulberry Bags to meet different people’s need, mulberry calf leather bags, mulberry patent leather bags, Mulberry Buffalo leather bags, Mulberry ostrich leather bags,etc. From oversized mulberry bags to small size mulberry bags, Mulberry Bags are very popular around the world. All kinds of Mulberry leather Bags with stylish style and fashion season, Mulberry Alexa Bags , Mulberry Bayswater Bags , Mulberry Mitzy Hobo , Mulberry Clutch Bags , Mulberry Handbags , Mulberry Mens Bags ,etc. Mulberry bag always keep pace with the trends of the times, so take mulberry leather bag will let you never out of date. </p>
<p> </p>